Sports Memorabilia & Baseball Cards Collectors Insurance

From the Topps T206 Wagner to the Bowman Mickey Mantle rookie card, to game-worn memorabilia, to everything in between, we’ve seen it all at American Collectors Insurance. Since 1976, we’ve provided collectors with the protection that they deserve with specialized sports memorabilia and sports trading cards insurance. We understand the fun and excitement of collecting because we share your passion, too. As collectors ourselves, we have a unique understanding of the joy your collection brings, and we make it our mission to protect it.

How Our Policy Protects Your Collectibles

Our policies provide coverage against many different types of risk, including:

Accidental Damage
Burglaries and Theft
Fire
Floods
Natural Disasters
Mysterious Disappearance (on scheduled items)
Loss/Damage During Shipment (with Collectors Choice Endorsement)

Learn More About Our Policy Features

Sports Memorabilia Insurance Autographed Baseball

Learn about rare vintage and antique collectibles

Online Resources for Sports Memorabilia Collectors

Whether you have an extensive collection or you’re just getting started, connect with other collectors, get values, and more.

Collectible Resources

Sports Memorabilia Insurance Policy Features

There are so many benefits of insuring your sports memorabilia collection, but it’s critical that the insurance you choose provides the features and protection that your hobby deserves. Here’s what you can expect out of your policy:

Agreed Value Coverage

Qualifying sports memorabilia collections are insured up to policy limits for their full collector value, less any deductible, and never depreciate. Coverage also applies to accessories and product packaging.

Extensive Coverage

What good is sports memorabilia and baseball cards collectors insurance if it doesn’t protect you against a variety of different accidents? Broad collectible coverage insures your memorabilia and trading cards from damage caused by accidental breakage, fire, flood, theft, hurricane, earthquakes, and more.

Industry Leading Service

As collectors, we have a unique understanding of what it means to be a collector. When you choose American Collectors Insurance, you’re dealing with a knowledgeable and attentive team with decades of experience covering our customer’s most prized assets. Should the day come when you need to file a claim against your policy, our kind and passionate team will make the claims process as quick and streamlined as possible.

Inflation Guard

The value of your collection isn’t fixed, and your coverage shouldn’t be, either. A policy from American Collectors ensures that your policy limits increases along with inflation. Your policy limit will appreciate by 2% each quarter, up to 8% annually, for all items in your collection valued at greater than $2,000.

Automatic Coverage For New Items

As long as there’s always a new piece to add, we’ll provide coverage from the day you purchase it for the first 30 days. We cover additions to your collection up to $2,000, just let us know within 30 days of adding it to your collection.

Collector’s Choice

Our Collector’s Choice endorsement provides extra coverage, protecting collectibles stored off-site and those used during special occasions. Learn more about Collector’s Choice in our Policy Enhancements page linked below.

Program Features and Availability Vary by State

Note that specific coverage options do vary by state, and sports memorabilia insurance varies from state to state. Please contact us for information on policy specifics in your area.

See how much your Sports Memorabilia could be worth.

How Much is My Sports Memorabilia Worth?

Learn More

Additional Resources

Collecting 101

January 9th, 2020

Are Your Collectibles Properly Insured?

December 16th, 2019

Top Reasons to Choose American Collectors Insurance Over Our Competition

It is important to understand the differences in policies and services being offered when making a decision between collector and classic car insurance companies. Reasons to Choose American Collectors Insurance over Our Competitors: Classic Car Insurance …

Buyer’s Guides